Before I get to today's post two updates. Version 2 of Boom and Zoom is on Wargames Vault. It hopefully streamlines and clarifies several rules based on players feedback. A couple of optional rules are also added. Finally some late war aircraft stats are tweaked to keep everyone in line with the upcoming British late war planes. Second, I have been playing around with Hail of Fire. I will review Hail of Fire in a separate post after more than two plays.
SAGA. Some people like the ancients/medieval game system and other decry it as "gamey", "ahistorical" and even "rubbish".
I am a super historical gamer. I have been playing ancients since Caesar was in diapers. SAGA is "gamey, ahistorical and rubbish. Rubbish I tell you!"
Though even its detractors [ haters if I am trying to be hip with the Swifties! I am sure many of them play it and read this blog.] have never said it isn't fun.
Its fun if you like playing Yahtzee.
In my formative years I played GMT's Great battles of History by Berg. So I knew about the battles and formations. I picked up SAGA V1 because it didn't require a lot of figures and looked different. I was living in England at the time, two hours from Sutton Hoo, so it was easy to imagine a Viking invasion. The game system was really fun! It was "gamey" and ahistorical so I tinkered with it to make it more "realistic". All I did was make it more complicated.
Complicated is good!
Version 2 came out and did indeed tidy up the system. Then I designed Cold War Tanker and some WW II games I never bothered to publish and finally Boom and Zoom. In designing these games I "designed for effect". I knew what I wanted the player to be faced with and feel. Some of the important considerations that his real life counterparts felt. [ or could have in the case of WW III.] As I went back to playing SAGA I realized that is exactly what the authors had been trying to do! All those "gamey rules" are actually trying to recreate a "feel" or some history of the various periods. [ There are several exceptions. Packs of dogs and flaming pigs; while historical seem a bit too prevalent too me!] Over the last two years, the more history I read the more I appreciate SAGAs subtle approach to being a fun and a quick play historical game. If you look at Boom and Zoom there are multiple mechanism inspired from SAGA.
Let me give you several examples from a design stand point:
First, don't think of SAGA as representing a skirmish of 40 men. Your 4 heathguards aren't 4 heathguards. They are a unit of 4 stands of elite infantry with as much strength as a normal unit of 8 stand infantry.
Command and Control: I use to think that SAGA had no C + C and even made rules for it. But it does. You roll order dice just like PCR. Any die can order elites, 66% of dice can order regular troops and 50% of dice can order green troops. Your commander can order any one stand within 4 inches. Gamey? No more so than many other games I have played.
That is a lot of Romans to command
"But what about using order dice for special abilities?". It is like taking a magic wand and giving my troops "special powers". Ahh, this is where the subtle design decisions come in. Each board has "special powers" unique to that board. This is to give you the flavor of the faction. Early boards were sometimes not balanced but with the last three ancient books they are all excellent. Lets look at the Caesar's Legions board from Age of Caesar since that is the one I am using currently learning.
Now as a designer what would I want the player to know/feel about the Romans as they transition from a republic to imperial?
1. The legions were well trained to fight as a group verses many of their enemies.
2. The legions fought in compact units that would get in close and often do significant damage more than their numbers indicate.
3. The legions had a strict hierarchy/discipline that helped keep troops together in times of peril.
4. The legion started to have loyalty to their commanders rather than the republic.
I don't think many "historical" gamers would argue with the above list.
So we could add lots of modifiers and special rules to our game to reflect the four points above for flavor. SAGA takes a different approach. We can use our order dice to highlight the above effects. The player has to balance using his limited dice to highlight historical effects of his troops vrs just getting them to move. Gamey? No more so than a laundry list of DRMs or saying you can't have a flank bonus because you are 2mm to far to the left.
Flank bonus is flank bonus. 2mm is 2mm! Details are important.
Some examples:
Legion Veterans: requires a rare die (6). Gain 1 attack die for each figure in your unit (max 6).
This is hard to activate but shows the times when everything clicks. The legion is able to get in close with a tight formation and inspired local leadership. Historical? I think so.
Legionnaires about to play Legion Veterans. It is nice when things work out.Pilum Requires a common die (1-3) Activate a legion for a shooting attack then charge. Can also be used in defense.
This was the standard way for the legion to attack. If anything this should be a standard ability rather than special. I suspect if it was standard it would upset play balance too much. Might play around with it if I get some time. Historical? Absolutely.
Trained Together Requires an uncommon (4-5) or rare (6) die. Activate 2 units or 3 if you use a rare die. At least one of these must be a legionnaire.
This goes back to #1 on our list and is a way to show the efficiency of the Roman war machine. Historical? Yes.
Well, I don't know. I like to hold on to my snap judgements. Even you can't defend the corruption rule where you can pay your legions in battle to give them "power ups".
Remember #4 on our list above? How would you try to show that in a game in an entertaining way? Since you know your history Rome and her armies were changing. Gone was the citizen soldier devoted to the republic. Political generals now wanted troops loyal to them in case they needed to cross the Rubicon. How do you get troops loyal to you? Treat them well and pay them well. SAGA introduces this loyalty through the mechanic called "corruption". I would have called it something else like "loyalty or charisma". Maybe it sounds better in french. You gets a certain number of corruption points to improve your troops. Historical? Caesar's troops fought much better than Pompey's troops man for man during the civil war. This would be a great way to differentiate the two sides using the same battle board if you wanted to be "historical".
Well it is still a dumb mechanic and this is a dumb post. BTW, you cherry picked the special powers you showed. How about Vae Victis from the Gaul/Briton board. If you win a melee a unit 4 inches away has to roll to see if they suffer a casualty? Do they die of fakeness?
Again subtlety here. The Gaelic people were frankly the most frightening people the Romans faced. They were considered great warriors and besting one in individual combat was a great feat of arms. They had sacked Rome once which the Romans had not forgotten. How do you build in this fear into your game? How about something like, "If a legion loses a melee every unit within 4 inches must take a morale check." Is that fake? Or you can have a special like Vae Victis [ which means "Woe to the vanquished"] and is a common ability. Every unit within 4 inches that just saw these beasts win a melee has to roll a die. They might take a casualty which isn't actually a casualty. It represents a combination of people straggling off and the loss of fighting power to the unit as their will to fight is sapped a little. Historical? Absolutely.
Well there may be some historical validity to SAGA but it is still a dumb game just like this post.
Fair enough. I am not trying to convince anyone to like SAGA. I am trying to convince you that is a quick play historical game. You can disagree with the design choices but there is historical thought behind them.
So next time someone brings out SAGA instead of being a hater, take a look at the battle board with an open mind. Or as Taylor Swift would say, " Baby just say yes."
Enjoy
Joe


No comments:
Post a Comment